 |











 |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
I put Michael Moore's documentary on my Netflix queue in an attempt to watch something "good for me". We started watching it Thursday evening. Cecil made it through about 20 minutes before she said it was too depressing to watch. She understands the insurance companies are basically evil, but she really didn't want to see it spelled out explicitly.
I made it through almost all of the rest myself. I had to stop just before the end as Moore takes a bunch of insurance-challenged people to Guantanamo Bay where the inmates have "universal health care". I didn't really need to see him pull stunts. I thought the rest of the movie was very well done. I liked his point that we already have socialized police, fire, education, and libraries, so why not medicine? (Not that police and education don't have major problems in some areas.) I also was amazed by the health care systems of Canada, Britain, and France. He counters potential arguments - are the lines too long? Nope. Are there hidden charges? Nope. Are the doctors not paid well? Nope. Are the taxes crippling to the middle class? Nope. Of course, he makes the mistake that my discrete math students often make. His "proof" is one doctor, one family, one hospital. You really can't generalize from that. And do all French mothers get a free nanny from the government (as Moore implies), or do you have to be below a certain income level?
I also thought he had a sobering point that one of the reasons we have the health care systems we do is that we're willing to accept it and not actively fight it. Maybe we all need to stand up more often.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |



|
 |
|
 |